
Comparing Costs
Ongoing System Operation and Replacement Costs
Installation cost is only part of the expense involved in owning and operating an access
control system. Ongoing operation and maintenance costs are also important, as people use
the access control system there will be lost or broken RF tags and damaged barcode decals
that must be replaced. For this comparison, we use the cost of replacing RF-ID tags and
barcode decals over the first 5 years of operation. While we cannot predict exactly how many
decals or tags will be replaced over a 5 year period, lets assume that 50% of them will need
to be replaced as people sell or trade in their old vehicles for new ones:
BAI barcode system:
500 Replacement decals = $1,995
To make a fair comparison, we assume that 50% of the RF-ID tags will need replacement
during the first 5 years the system operates:
RF system:
500 Replacement passive (no battery) RF-ID tags = $9,000
Next, consider the costs of maintenance on the readers. The BAI readers have a 5 year
Limited Warranty, which covers it for half of the anticipated lifespan. RF-ID readers generally
have a 1 year Warranty.
As this comparison shows, the barcode system will have significantly lower operation and
maintenance costs than the RF-ID system. RF-ID tags are the most expensive part of the RF
system, and yet they must be replaced when lost, damaged, or stop functioning.
Summary of installation and 5 year operating and maintenance costs
BAI reader system initial installation = $12,790
BAI reader system maintenance = $ 1,995
Cost projection over 5 years = $14,785
RF-ID system initial installation = $24,000
RF-ID reader system maintenance = $ 9,000
Cost projection over 5 years = $33,000
These costs are intended for equipment purchase comparison only and do not address all of
the equipment and costs involved in a site installation. Please consult a systems integrator for
a complete system installation cost estimate.
Ver. 1.8 Barcode Automation, inc 800-528-9167 FAX: 407-327-6172 6
Kommentare zu diesen Handbüchern